Brothers in Arms

We recently crossed to Mull on the Oban to Craignure ferry, a short journey on the waters of the Firth of Lorne and the southern reaches of the Sound of Mull.  As the Caledonian MacBrayne ferry leaves Oban, it passes between Alexander Carrick’s War Memorial on the mainland to the east and the Isle of Kerrara to the west.  The Brothers in Arms sculpture, erected in 1923, is considered Carrick’s masterpiece and depicts a wounded soldier supported on each arm by his comrades; in turn their arms support his legs to form a cupped circle.  Perhaps the circular composition symbolises the passing of time and how we are locked into an endless cycle of catastrophic repetition.  It is reminiscent of Don McCullin’s 1968 picture of an American marine supported by his brothers in arms, having been shot in both legs during the Têt offensive at Hué.  Both sculpture and image have been compared to the crucifixion.

Years later I went back to Hué…..It seemed so inconsequential, the whole thing…..those men who died, and those men who were maimed for life, went through all that, and it was totally futile, as all wars are known to be.  Without profit, without horizons, without joy.  I remember there was a street in Da Nang called Street without Joy.  They could have called the whole country after that street – Don McCullin – Unreasonable Behaviour.

Brothers in Arms

(click on image to enlarge)


  1. greenmackenzie · June 21, 2013

    A beautiful sculpture, beautifully captured….and I couldn’t agree more with your posts sentiments on war and its ultimate futility.

    • northumbrianlight · June 21, 2013

      Thanks Seonaid it is a wonderful memorial; there are so many in cities, towns and villages which of itself speaks volumes. I am a great admirer of McCullin, a tortured soul who has earned the right to speak and be listened to.

  2. meticulousmick · June 21, 2013

    Nice picture, beautiful words. I continue to get jealous of journeying through that area. To go one step further I am sure that a close up of an otter dissecting a fish will soon appear on your blog. MM 😦

  3. Tish Farrell · June 21, 2013

    ‘Like’ doesn’t seem the right response to this imposing and moving monument, caught so dramatically by you. Very moving. If only everyone could remember that war is futile. There scarcely seems a time when we aren’t marching into one, or thinking about doing so.

    • northumbrianlight · June 21, 2013

      Thanks Tish – without wishing to be overtly ‘political’ I do wonder how certain people sleep at night.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s